![]() |
| |||||||
| Sydney Biodiesel Supplies Please post here any information on local suppliers of equipment or materials for making or using biodiesel in Sydney. |
![]() |
| | LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
| ||||
| Acetone in Fuel
Thought some members may be interested in this article, and wonder if it would benefit in bio use. Don't forget to scan down and look at the graphs. 2 ounces acetone to 10 U.S. gallons of diesel seems to produce the best results. Very interesting. http://www.lubedev.com/smartgas/additive.htm |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
I wasn't impressed with some of his reasoning, things like cold weather increases power because it increases the viscosity of the air - it doesn't it increases its density. However, looking past his attempts to explain the phenomena, if it does what he says, then it doesn't matter if his attempts to explain are correct - it just does it. I have used acetone as an octane enhancer in petrol engines. I've seen mixes up to 15%, but 5% is more common. The acetone takes a lot of heat to break down the structure of the fuel. That translates into slower burning, thus it can help impede detonation. I have never heard of it being used in diesel fuel. If anything, it seems contraindicated, that is, we don't want to raise the octane of the diesel fuel. However, if his graph is correct (I have no idea how he obtained the figures for the graph) then a very small bit of acetone may increase the mileage. Does it do it for biodiesel? He mentions vegetable fuels, so maybe he is referring to biodiesel. The figure of 2 oz per 10 gallons (US) translates to 59.14cc to 37.9 litres. Say, 60cc for 38 litres. That is not much acetone and I would be comfortable trying that in my vehicle - so I will. Like he says, find 100% pure acetone, the one without the evaporation inhibitor in it. If he gets that much extra mileage, then there should be a corresponding increase in power. If there is no power increase, then I can't see how mileage can increase. I just checked my math. Bugger if I know how I got all those conversions from oz/gal to litres??. The best method is just using a percentage - .2% of 38 litres is 76cc. (80cc in 40 litres, etc.) That is a bit more acetone, but I will still give it a try as I'm sure the engine could take a lot more. As I am not driving that much every week, I am going to mention it over on another forum and see if anyone else wants to try it. Last edited by Terry Syd; 25th June 2006 at 09:50 AM. |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
Tell a rev head engineer in the car racing game that ethanol (pure biofuel) is bad for your car and he'll laugh in your face. The world record fastest thing on the drag strip (notwithstanding jetpower) is burning Zero greenhouse emission biofuel.--ETHANOL>>>spot on!!! I just learned yesterday from Andy Fischer, that General Motors Holden is selling an Australian made Holden to the Brazilians that perfectly runs on E85. In Brazil you can buy almost pure Ethanol (E85%) at the servo and fill up your Monaro on it.....>>>THEY HAVE BEEN SELLING FOR 3 YEARS NOW I think. Meanwhile in Australia, according to Oil Corporations and Howard Gov. PROPAGANDA, just 18 months ago GMH and Ford Australia would not warranty new cars on any ethanol blend. 3 months ago after the most recent peak oil spike, the opposition (fat man Beazly) stated they would have a policy at the next election to invest in biofuels. Immidiatly, the same day, little johnny brownnose did a total backflip(ACROBAT A -LA -CLASS) and got his mates at GMH and Ford Australia to sing along. The stupid thing is , thanks to little johnny's PROPAGANDA(HE NEEDS TO GET THE ADD MAN OF THE YEAR), Many people still belive the hype, and some fuel stations even have stickers on their premium unleaded bowsers saying " no ethanol" . If anyone can honestly testify to Ethanol stalling their car , they Probably haven't serviced their car for so long its simply so out of tune so far that its burning rich and dirty , no wonder the clean burning fuel stalled the car, " .Oh but little johnny said it might damage my engine, even though not servicing and tuning my car will definitely damage my engine" LITTLE JOHNY IS DANGEROUS!!! And we think we can beat them (Brazil) at football!!??......LETS GET THE CUP HOME 2010....AUssie Aussie Aussie...oi,oi,oi,...we gave them a run for there money but...(Besides selling our Holdens). When the Fat Boy and the Little Man gets the act together...that will be the Day.I am an optimist. |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
Some further research indicates that this 'acetone in fuel' concept has been done to death on a number of forums. Some people report some success, others say nothing happened. The best result I could find were comments of 10-15% increase in mileage. The Toyota Surf forum had a number of threads on it. The general concensus was if it did anything, that about 60cc for 40 litres of diesel (or biodiesel) was about the right mix. I tried a bit and noticed that it did change the engine tone a little. There seemed to be a bit more low-end power. I didn't notice anything at full power. It may be that it works, but how well may depend upon your driving technique. In fact, if it tends to help with a bit more low-end torque, then maybe it is encouraging people to change their driving technique so that they 'short shift' the engine and keep it in the sweet spot of the powerband. That may explain why some have reported an increase and others have not. This is an idea that needs to be put on a dyno and tested using two fuels and a switching valve. You could switch back and forth between the fuels and monitor the power and fuel flow. Trying to make an accurate assessment with the many variables of on-road driving is not very scientific. |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel Quote:
Furthermore the addition of small percentages of ethanol to petrol only rises the overall petroleum bill for a country if you take into account the amount of fuel burned to produce ethanol and the additional fuel used because of the loss of milage suffered by the car using a mix. If taken up in a major national scale like in Brazil the proposition may have a positive balance. The way we had it allowing petrol station owners to adulterate fuel behind the back of the unsuspected motorist who paid through the nose with repairs, brake downs and fires, to save 2 cents and allowing the criminal owner of the petrol station to make bigger profits is absurd. Biofuel, yes. Criminal adulteration, no. |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
While admitting I have no experience or knowledge to draw from, 60ml or acetone in 40L of diesel seems far too small a ratio to be of any effect at all. I know speedway racers used to use it ( and may still do) but it was in ratios of around 10% not .0015% as an additive to diesel fuel, I have to wonder if the mix were to be analyzed if the acetone could actually be found amongst all the other compounds in the fuel at that ratio. 60Ml in 40 L works out at .0015% to me, the numbers of that seem to be just too small in something that is as relatively impure and non constant as the chemistry of diesel which is changed and does have tolerances. A quick look up of diesel composition says that diesel is made up of 25% aromatics which covers a few different compounds which may vary. To me, the addition of another .0015% aromatic seems unlikely in the extreme to be capable of changing the fuels properties enough to give such a marked difference in economy, especially when diesel is not a pure substance to start with and its composition can change widely from source to source. As for the article, it seems there is nothing more scientific in the claims the guy has made other than saying he drives 70 miles one way on one fuel, runs a tank of normal fuel and then does the test with the additive. As this is presumably done at a later date, the myriad of factors that could have changed and altered the test results make the exercise completely meaningless. Differences in temperature,, humidity, wind speed and direction and traffic would be more than enough to render any test results useless. As far as the properties the author of the article talks about in acetone, I believe the same thing could be accomplished with the addition of Nitro methane. This is used by racers as it too is a very slow burning fuel and I believe also releases a lot of oxygen when it is burned. I would like to see some proper controlled scientific tests done on the addition of acetone but until I do see something I can believe in, I am going to find it very hard to believe that the addition of a substance at a ratio of .0015% is able to release enough additional energy from a fuel to propel a vehicle another 3-4 Miles per gallon. |
| ||||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
David, nice to see you rationalising it all. However, I have been using it since I made the first post in this thread (@60ml per 38 litres) and have noticed a marked increase in power at the low end and a noticeable improvement in diesel consumption. This is with both bio and dino fuel. I think the power improvement means I use less throttle to get where I want to when taking off, thus leading to the improvement in fuel usage. Whatever, it is working for me and I'll keep using it. Now, I wish I could stop breaking CV joints in the bush. |
| |||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
Hi Yorta2, As you give this a first hand reccomendation, I would like to test it for myself. I may be a sceptic but I am an open minded sceptic and am only too willing to change my mind in light of new discoveries. ![]() I notice the article makes mention of certain types of acetone being the ones to use. Can you tell me what I should look for and the best places to source it from? I appreciate the qty's involved are small but do you buy it in bulk, say a litre or 5 at a time and if so, how much do you pay for it? With fuel being the price it is, I would be keen to try it in my petrol car to see if I can notice any improvement in that. The article quotes 25% improvement in performance/ economy which is certainly significant enough to notice by seat of the pants measurement. I was thinking of a test I could do myself with diesel. I have just bought a Diesel engined water pump which I am intending to use the engine from to power a generator. I'm thinking if I put a constant load on the thing ( either by pumping water or by electrical load) and measure the run time for say a litre of fuel, I certainly should be able to see if there is any difference between fuel with and without acetone particularly if I run the tests 3 times each. ( wow, a test like this could cost up to 10 Bucks in fuel! )I think a test like that, as rough as it would be, could certainly give results which were definative enough to either prove or disprove the acetone theroy and would be enough to potentially change my mind. Just re-reading previous posts, I see Terry suggested a valve to switch fuels mid run as it were which also seems a good way of measuring power. I wonder if the engine I have could be loaded up and then measurements of RPM be taken with one of those optical tacho's to get an indication of any changes this way. As long as the engine was loaded to hold the rpms below the max goverend speed I think this would be a sound test also. Now, how do I simply and cheaply fully load up a 6.5 HP engine? I do have a couple of ways to measure exhaust temp. I believe this is significant on diesels but do not know why, Can anyone tell me what a higher or lower EGT means in relation to the power being produced? |
| ||||
| Re: Acetone in Fuel
David, I had a one litre bottle of Glendale Acetone 99% W/W sitting in a cupboard under our kitchen sink that had been there for years - I am using that. I think acetone can be easily bought from hardware stores, such as Mitre 10 and Bunnings, and costs something like $10.00 per litre, but might be cheaper in bulk. (Not sure why I had this one, but probably for cleaning up an epoxy spill at some time - can't really remember.) At the rate I am using it, for my full 66 litre tank I only need about 104ml of acetone, so will get over 9 tanks with the litre. Not too expensive for experimentation. I would think that 99% is about as pure as I will get it. Good luck with your pump tests.
|
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
LinkBacks (?)
LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.biofuelsforum.com/sydney_biodiesel_supplies/443-acetone_fuel.html | ||||
| Posted By | For | Type | Date | |
| Science a GoGo's Discussion Forums: Improve your mileage. | This thread | Refback | 6th May 2007 03:07 PM | |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| The ATO issue - Is the Taxman going to chase you? | Robert | General Biodiesel Discussion | 46 | 15th October 2006 07:23 AM |
| There is no fuel like an old fuel by Dr Geoffrey Chia | Marc1 | General Biodiesel Discussion | 7 | 25th August 2006 11:02 PM |
| Extra Fuel Filter | RossH | Using Biodiesel | 27 | 24th August 2006 08:37 PM |
| Fuel Tax Bill 2006 and Biodiesel | Robert | Australian Biodiesel Industry Forum | 2 | 21st June 2006 02:09 AM |
| Finally!!! | Olaf | SVO Users | 9 | 11th November 2005 09:06 PM |