Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2 Stage process - dropout calculation

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • tillyfromparadise
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Hi Mark,
    You have certainly been busy on this forum this afternoon

    Originally posted by Dr Mark View Post
    You haven't answered these questions, Tillyfromparadise. Why would that be?
    If I were to tell people that I actually had a PhD in chemistry, they would stop thinking of me as a loveable larrikin and start calling me "Dr Tilly". I don't want that to happen!



    Then why do you heat it? Heating is an extra step that requires extra hardware and costs money.
    Until last year I did all my heating in the sun. There was no extra hardware or money cost.
    As WesleyB has explained several times, the reaction goes faster the warmer things are. I am surprised you seem to keep forgetting this.

    Because I use a paint mixer in a drill to mix, it was more convenient to heat the oil in the sun until about 1 pm when the oil would usually be around 50- 55deg C Then I would add the methoxide and mix on and off for an hour. I would do two 50 litre batches simultaneously.
    Then I would allow the glycerine to settle for about 45 minutes, drain the glycerine and perform a second stage.

    Last year I upsized the reactors to 130 litres each and started using electric heating. At the same time I started using a pump to move liquids around instead of carrying them in buckets and pails.
    I also had to pay $10 to upsize my paint mixer.
    I have reached the age where I am willing to pay an extra half cent a litre to produce my biodiesel and not be absolutely buggered at the end of the day from all the toting and carrying.

    If I can provide you with any further help just ask. I have a lot of experience.
    Last edited by tillyfromparadise; 23 October 2013, 03:08 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr Mark
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Originally posted by tillyfromparadise View Post
    Hi Mark,
    And yet I have known for years that the base only transesterification method used to make biodiesel will proceed quite happily at room temperature.
    Isn't that remarkable!
    .
    Then why do you heat it? Heating is an extra step that requires extra hardware and costs money.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr Mark
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Originally posted by Dr Mark View Post
    Yes, it is. The concepts involved in biodiesel manufacture are concepts that would be taught at 3rd year level as part of a chemistry degree.

    If you don't have such an education, why on earth do you think you understand it?

    But feel free to prove me wrong. The two steps in the acid/base method occur by very different mechanisms. What are those two mechanisms, and what implications are there for reaction kinetics and selection of reactant and catalyst concentrations?
    You haven't answered these questions, Tillyfromparadise. Why would that be?

    Leave a comment:


  • WesleyB
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    I used anhydrous isopropyl alcohol in the transesterification reaction plus KOH plus new corn oil plus heat and magnetic stirring. There was little or no transesterification reaction occurred. Then I used sulfuric acid + anhydrous isopropyl alcohol + stearic acid (a free fatty acid) plus heat and stirring to get isopropyl stearate plus water. I washed and dried the isopropyl stearate to get the sulphuric acid out. I have read that isopropyl stearate has better cold flow properties than methyl stearate, so I made a little. I think, without looking it up that stearic acid melts at about 70 degrees centigrade. In many vegatable oils stearic acid is a component. It has 18 carbon chain length. Methyl stearate is a component of regular biodiesel. I think they call it high melting methyl esters. On cold days it solidifies out of methyl biodiesel ( fractional crystalization ). I think Isopropyl stearate has a lower melting point than methyl stearate. Isopropyl stearate can also be called octadecanoic acid -2-propyl ester, or 2-propyl octadecanoate. The isopropyl ester might be better for winter use.

    Leave a comment:


  • Tony From West Oz
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Originally posted by WesleyB View Post
    Tillyfromparadise; I haven't found my notes on this one. I dissolved enough potassium hydroxide in anhydrous isopropyl alcohol to neutralise some stearic acid. I melted the stearic acid and poured it into the potassium hydroxide/ isopropyl alcohol solution. I mixed it up with a glass stirring rod. About 30 minutes later the reaction flask was still warm. I think the reaction was exothermic. It took longer than I thought it would to make the potassium stearate (potassium soap). I'll look some more for my notes on this reaction.
    Why are you using Isopropyl Alcohol in a biodiesel reaction?
    Most people use Methyl alcohol to produce Methyl Esters, in rare cases, Ethyl Alcohol is used to make Ethyl Esters, but I have never heard of anyone creating Isopropyl Esters for biodiesel.

    Was this a human error when typing the post, or are you doing something special here?

    Regards,
    Tony

    Leave a comment:


  • WesleyB
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    In addition, glycerol is a drying agent, so removing the glycerine layer after the first stage would remove some of the water from the reaction material. He didn't say that. But glycerine only adsorbs so much water.

    Leave a comment:


  • tillyfromparadise
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Hi WesleyB,
    The quick answer is that you can achieve the same results using less methanol.

    This explanation is from the Chemist "neutral"
    "It is of course an equilibrium reaction. It will go to the right forever but so slowly you will not see anything after an hour or so, stirring at 50 deg C. And it will never go all the way no matter how long it is run - that is the nature of an equilibrium reaction.
    At the end of the first stage, when equilibrium is reached (almost), all components are present in fixed ratios. In particular there is methanol (reactant) and glycerol (product) in solution in the upper layer in a fixed ratio. The amount of glycerol in the reaction zone, the upper layer, is low and fixed mainly by its solubility.
    If we now add say another 10% methanol/NaOH and stir we will have a new and higher ratio of methanol to glycerol. This extra methanol will be distributed between the upper and lower layers, more in the lower layer than in the upper, and will push the reaction a little to the right.

    But if instead we drain most of the glycerine before adding the extra 10% methanol/NaOH there will be little lower layer to share it. Therefore the methanol content of the upper layer will be much higher. The glycerol content of the upper layer will be no different so the methanol/glycerol ratio in the upper layer will be much higher. The reaction will be pushed further to the right than if we had left the glycerine there."


    I even understand what I have just posted

    "

    Leave a comment:


  • WesleyB
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    The transesterification reaction is fairly fast in near anhydrous conditions. But KOH + methanol produces some water. The neutralisation reaction produces water as it proceeds. Acid plus base yields salt (soap) plus water. The saponification reaction requires water to proceed. So as the neutralisation reaction proceeds, producing water, the saponification reaction rate increases. And the production of water in the reaction material impedes and slows down the transesterification reaction. So I'm still not clear on any benefit to doing a base base transesterification reaction on high titration oil (a two stage reaction rather than a one stage reaction).

    Leave a comment:


  • tillyfromparadise
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Hi WesleyB,
    Your original post was about methanol, not isopropyl.
    I have done no testing with isopropyl so I can not help you with that.
    However, I can answer your original question. "If I have a KOH titration vegetable oil of 16 or so, what will happen if I dissolve 8 grams of KOH in 200 milliliters of ahydrous methanol and mix it with one litre of the dry high titration oil at say 60 degrees centigrade for about an hour?

    On a brighter note, Mark's explanation about saponification being faster than transesterification is correct.

    Leave a comment:


  • WesleyB
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    I found my notes on neutralising stearic acid with potassium hydroxide in anhydrous isopropyl alcohol. Put 4 grams 90% KOH into 100 ml anhydrous isopropyl alcohol at about 25 degrees centigrade. Dissolved the KOH in the alcohol with magnetic stirring. Melted 18.25 grams stearic acid in a 250 ml beaker. Managed to pour about 14 grams of the stearic acid into the KOH/isopropyl alcohol solution. I stirred with a glass rod. About 30 minutes later the reaction flask was still warm. The reaction was exothermic and slower than I thought it would be. 18.25 grams of stearic acid is an equimolar amount to 4 grams 90% KOH. There was plenty of KOH present to do a neutralisation reaction with the stearic acid (a free fatty acid). Since the soap making was slower than I thought it would be, I wonder if transesterification proceeds at about the same rate. I was considering how to remove free fatty acids from high titration vegetable oil without allowing transesterification to proceed. When I tried to make Isopropyl biodiesel from vegetable oil and anhydrous isopropyl alcohol and KOH there was little or no transesterification reaction.

    Leave a comment:


  • WesleyB
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Tillyfromparadise; I haven't found my notes on this one. I dissolved enough potassium hydroxide in anhydrous isopropyl alcohol to neutralise some stearic acid. I melted the stearic acid and poured it into the potassium hydroxide/ isopropyl alcohol solution. I mixed it up with a glass stirring rod. About 30 minutes later the reaction flask was still warm. I think the reaction was exothermic. It took longer than I thought it would to make the potassium stearate (potassium soap). I'll look some more for my notes on this reaction.

    Leave a comment:


  • tillyfromparadise
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Hi WesleyB,
    The offer still stands. Anytime you want me to provide the answer just let me know

    Leave a comment:


  • tillyfromparadise
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Hi Mark,
    Originally posted by Dr Mark View Post
    Yes, it is. The concepts involved in biodiesel manufacture are concepts that would be taught at 3rd year level as part of a chemistry degree.

    If you don't have such an education, why on earth do you think you understand it?
    And yet I have known for years that the base only transesterification method used to make biodiesel will proceed quite happily at room temperature.
    Isn't that remarkable!

    In fact, in my early days, when I was testing everything because there is so much inaccurate information posted on the internet about making biodiesel (such as people saying the biodiesel base transesterification reaction must be performed at an elevated temperature), I found that as long as everything remained liquid, the reaction proceeded in my fridge when everything had been first cooled to around 5 deg C.
    Last edited by tillyfromparadise; 28 September 2013, 04:20 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr Mark
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Didn't see this before, sorry - I don't come here very often:

    Maybe you could tell me, If I have a KOH titration vegetable oil of 16 or so, what will happen if I dissolve 8 grams of KOH in 200 milliliters of ahydrous methanol and mix it with one litre of the dry high titration oil at say 60 degrees centigrade for about an hour? Is transesterification faster than the expecteted neutralisation and saponification reaction? If transesterification occurs significantly, then I could see a two stage method might be justified. Thanks
    More information is required:

    1. What is the concentration of the KOH titrant?
    2. What is the volume of the WVO aliquot you are titrating?

    But in general:
    Is transesterification faster than the expecteted neutralisation and saponification reaction?
    Since all that is required for soap formation is deprotonation of the FFA (neutralisation):

    FFAH + Na+ + H3CO- = Na-FFA(soap) + H3COH (methanol)

    It's always going to be faster than the transesterification. The rate-determining factor will be how much water is in system, what the consequent micellar concentration will be, and whether the methoxide carries out the esterification before it partitions into the hydrophilic micelles and is therefore removed as a catalyst

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr Mark
    replied
    Re: 2 Stage process - dropout calculation

    Originally posted by tillyfromparadise View Post
    Hi Mark,

    It does not worry me what you take the answer to be. Is it important?.
    Yes, it is. The concepts involved in biodiesel manufacture are concepts that would be taught at 3rd year level as part of a chemistry degree.

    If you don't have such an education, why on earth do you think you understand it?

    But feel free to prove me wrong. The two steps in the acid/base method occur by very different mechanisms. What are those two mechanisms, and what implications are there for reaction kinetics and selection of reactant and catalyst concentrations?

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X